By Millie Nemser
This fall, Rye Country Day School welcomed Ms. Doshi to the College Counseling Office. With experience as both a high school English teacher and an admissions officer at the University of St. Andrews in Scotland, Doshi brings a unique perspective to the college process. After spending the past four years reviewing applications and meeting with prospective students, she is excited to return to a school environment where she can work closely with students every day.
Doshi grew up in Queens, New York, and was always particularly interested in the humanities. She was also a swimmer and consequently holds the belief that sports play an important role in students’ lives. She went on to become an English teacher at a high school in Brooklyn, where she taught tenth and twelfth grade and served as a senior dean. After twelve years of living on the Upper East Side, Doshi and her family moved to the Bedford-Katonah area during the COVID-19 pandemic. With twins, Jasper and Zora, now in third grade, she decided to take a break from teaching and explore a different side of education.
She began working in admissions at the University of St Andrews, where she spent four years reading college applications, visiting high schools, and attending college fairs. One of her favorite parts of the job was getting to learn about so many different students through their applications. Reading about their backgrounds, interests, and accomplishments gave her a new understanding of the many ways students can stand out in the admissions process. Her time at St. Andrews also taught her that “success does not always look one way.” While grades and academic achievements are important, she emphasized that what students accomplish outside the classroom can be just as meaningful. She also gained firsthand experience with how quickly admissions officers read applications, something she hopes will help her guide RCDS students as they prepare their own.
After four years in admissions, Doshi found herself missing the daily interactions she had enjoyed as a teacher. Although she loved learning about students through their applications, she wanted to get to know them beyond what they could fit on a few pages. Rye Country Day was already familiar to her. During her time at St. Andrews, she had visited RCDS to meet with prospective applicants and had gotten to know members of the College Counseling Office. When the opportunity to join the department arose, she was excited about the chance to return working directly with students.
One of the things Doshi missed most about teaching was the relationships she formed with students, both inside and outside the classroom. In addition to teaching English, she had served as an advisor to a Gender and Sexuality Alliance club, an experience she found especially meaningful because of the guidance and support she could provide students. For Doshi, college counseling brings together the best parts of teaching and admissions. She enjoys getting to know students, learning about their interests, and helping them figure out ways to present themselves throughout the application process.
She described the college application process as “a storytelling journey,” one that allows students to discover more about themselves along the way. Because of her English expertise, she particularly enjoys helping students “connect the dots” between their different interests, activities, and experiences to create a narrative that reflects who they are. Whether through academics, athletics, extracurricular activities, or personal experiences, she hopes to help students recognize what makes their individual stories worth telling.
When asked what advice she would give students beginning the college process, Doshi stressed the importance of doing things out of genuine enjoyment, not simply because they might look good on an application. Her advice was to “do things that genuinely give you joy” and to pursue them “for the sake of the activity,” rather than worrying about how they will appear to colleges. Having read countless applications, she explained that admissions officers can often tell when a student is participating in an activity just to check a box. In fact, she joked that “admissions people can smell that from a mile away.” Rather than trying to build what they think is the perfect resume, she encourages students to explore their interests and spend time doing things they are truly passionate about. Doshi also emphasized that success looks different for everyone. Not every student needs to follow the same path or participate in the same activities to have a meaningful high school experience. For Doshi, authenticity is far more important than trying to create an impressive list of accomplishments.
Her most important reminder to students is that not everything they do in high school needs to be preparation for college. “Live your life,” Doshi advised, reminding students that they are “only a kid once.” She hopes students will take advantage of their high school years to try new things, spend time doing what they love, and enjoy themselves without constantly thinking about how every decision might affect their college applications.
With her background in teaching and admissions, Doshi hopes to make the college process feel less daunting for students, and more like an opportunity to reflect on their experiences, discover what matters to them, and share their stories. As she settles into her new role at RCDS, she is most looking forward to building relationships with students and becoming part of the school community.
